Here at Empire Plumbing in New York City, our master plumbers are known for their work with gas pipes. Our LL 152 services are our most popular choice, as these are due every four years for most residential properties with more than 3 residencies. But, as gas specialists, we are also occasionally called upon for things like installation – especially during a home renovation.
Often, homeowners are given the choice between gas and electric. This choice may seem simple, but is one of the most important choices you’ll make for your long term comfort.
Gas vs Electric
There are many factors that determine whether gas or electricity is the better option for heating your home, powering your appliances, and providing hot water. These include cost, efficiency, reliability, and even safety. Each energy source has its advantages, and understanding them can help you make a more informed decision for your property.
Heating and Efficiency
Gas appliances typically provide faster and more consistent heating. When used for furnaces, boilers, and water heaters, natural gas systems can quickly generate heat and maintain it for long periods with minimal fluctuation.
Gas cooking appliances are also favored by many homeowners and chefs because of their precise temperature control and ability to provide immediate heat, with no warm up period.
Electric systems, on the other hand, tend to be more energy efficient at the point of use, as nearly all the electricity is converted directly into heat, but take a while to heat up and may not be used as efficiently by the user. Electric heat also may struggle to maintain warmth in very cold weather.
Cost and Maintenance Considerations
In NY, natural gas remains less expensive than electricity for home heating and cooking. Because gas produces more heat energy per dollar, homeowners with gas furnaces or water heaters often experience lower monthly utility costs. However, the difference in cost can fluctuate based on market prices and local infrastructure.
Gas systems typically require more frequent inspections and maintenance due to the potential for leaks, pressure changes, and combustion safety. This is especially true in New York City, where Local Law 152 requires regular inspection of gas lines by a licensed master plumber. Electric systems generally require less ongoing maintenance and can often last longer without needing repair.
However, electric heating may be more prone to other challenges. Because it relies on wires, rats and decay can lead to electrical malfunction.
Choosing What’s Right for Your Home
There is no single answer that fits every property. In older New York City buildings already equipped with gas lines, it often makes sense to continue using gas systems, especially when efficiency and heating performance are priorities. Newer or renovated homes that emphasize sustainability may find that electric appliances – especially those powered by solar panels or modern heat pumps – offer long-term benefits, but come with several of the heating drawbacks that electricity is known for.